In accordance with federal law No. 35-FZ “On the Electric Power Industry” dated March 26, 2003, the subjects of the electric power industry include persons (organizations) engaged in the production of electric, thermal energy and power, the purchase and sale electrical energy and capacity, power supply to consumers, provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy, operational dispatch control in the power industry, sales of electrical energy (capacity), organization of the purchase and sale of electrical energy and capacity.
Functioning of the power system Russian Federation is based on a combination of technological and commercial infrastructure operating under state control, on the one hand, and organizations interacting in a competitive environment that generate and sell electricity.
Technological infrastructure organizations include: a company that manages the unified national electric grid (Public Joint Stock Company Federal Grid Company of the Unified Energy System (PJSC FGC UES)) an organization that performs dispatch control (Joint Stock Company System Operator of the Unified Energy System (JSC SO UES)), an operator of energy networks in Russia - 37 subsidiaries and affiliates, including 14 Russian Grids Public Joint Stock Company (Rosseti PJSC). The commercial infrastructure includes Joint Stock Company "Administrator trading system Wholesale Electricity Market" - JSC "ATS" and its subsidiary Joint-Stock Company "Center for Financial Settlements" - abbreviated as JSC "CFR". The activities of infrastructure organizations, including pricing and terms of interaction with counterparties, are subject to state regulation.
Generating companies generate and sell electricity on the wholesale or retail markets to sales organizations or large end consumers - wholesale market participants. Sales organizations purchase electricity in the wholesale and retail markets and sell it to end consumers. Purchase and sale of electricity and capacity by generating companies, sales organizations, grid organizations and large consumers participating in the wholesale electricity and capacity market is carried out in accordance with the Rules for the operation of the wholesale electricity and capacity market and the Agreement on joining the trading system of the wholesale electricity and capacity market. Signing of the Accession Agreement and joining the self-regulatory organization of participants in the wholesale electricity and capacity market (Association "Non-profit partnership Market Council for the organization effective system wholesale and retail trade in electric energy and capacity”, abbreviated as the Association “NP Council of the Market”) is prerequisite participation in the purchase and sale of electricity and capacity at wholesale market.
In accordance with federal law No. 36-FZ "On the peculiarities of the functioning of the electric power industry in the transition period and on amending certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation and recognizing as invalid some legislative acts of the Russian Federation in connection with the adoption of the federal law "On the electric power industry"" to combine the activities of transmission of electric energy and operational dispatch management in the electric power industry with activities for the production and purchase and sale of electric energy from the date of the end of the transitional period of reforming the electric power industry (2011) to groups of persons and af branched persons within the same price zone of the wholesale market is prohibited. Thus, the combination within the same price zone of natural monopoly activities with competitive ones is not allowed, at the same time, in competitive activities, the combination different types activity is possible (for example, a generation company may own sales organizations, but may not own networks).
In its current form, the wholesale electricity market has been functioning since September 1, 2006, when new rules for the functioning of the wholesale electricity (capacity) market were introduced by a decree of the Government of the Russian Federation.
Operational dispatch control in the unified energy system of Russia is carried out by the System Operator (JSC SO UES). The main function of the System Operator is to control compliance with the technological parameters of the functioning of the power system. To perform this function, the System Operator may issue mandatory commands to generating and grid companies, consumers with regulated load. The System Operator also controls the order in which generating and grid capacities are put into repair, and exercises control over the execution of investment programs by generating and grid companies.
The System Operator participates in ensuring the functioning of the wholesale electricity and capacity market: it updates the calculation model, on the basis of which the Commercial Operator calculates the volumes and prices of trade in the wholesale electricity market, conducts a competitive power take-off (CTO) and ensures the functioning of the balancing market - trading in deviations from the planned volumes of production and consumption of electricity.
Grid organizations carry out two main types of activities - the transmission of electric energy through electric networks and the technological connection of power receiving devices of electricity consumers, power plants of generating companies and power grid facilities of other owners to electric networks. Both of these activities are natural monopolies and are regulated by the state.
Regulation includes not only the establishment, in one form or another, of appropriate tariffs (fees) for services rendered proper quality services, but also ensuring non-discriminatory access of consumers of services of network organizations to electric networks.
Services for the transmission of electrical energy are provided by the grid organization on the basis of an agreement on the provision of paid services for the transmission of electrical energy. The contract for the provision of transmission services is public, that is, it essential conditions determined by the Government of the Russian Federation. Public contracts are obligatory for the conclusion by the network organization at the request of the consumer of services.
The contract for the provision of transmission services must contain the following essential conditions:
- value maximum power power receiving devices for each connection point;
- the value of the declared capacity, within which the grid organization assumes the obligation to ensure the transmission of electric energy at the points of connection specified in the contract;
- responsibility of the consumer of services and the grid organization for the condition and maintenance of electric grid facilities, within the boundaries of the balance sheet belonging of the grid organization and the consumer;
- obligations of the parties to equip points of connection with electrical energy measuring instruments that comply with the requirements established by the legislation of the Russian Federation, as well as to ensure their operability.
Smagin A.V., master of private law.
The presence in the Civil Code of norms fixing public law
elements, reflects not only the features of the transitional
period of the economy, but, obviously, national traits
future Russian market that can provide
harmony of interests and stability of public life<1>.
<1>Yakushev V.S. Civil Code Russia (part two) - continuation of the formation of market legislation (general legal characteristic) // Russian legal journal. 1996. N 2. S. 16.The electric power industry is a branch of the economy of the Russian Federation, which includes a complex economic relations arising in the process of production (including production in the mode of combined generation of electric and thermal energy), transmission of electric energy, operational dispatch control in the electric power industry, sale and consumption of electric energy using production and other property facilities (including those included in the Unified Energy System of Russia), owned by the right of ownership or otherwise provided for federal laws on the basis of electric power industry entities or other persons. This concept is contained in Art. 3 of the Federal Law of March 26, 2003 N 35-FZ "On the electric power industry"<2>(hereinafter referred to as the Federal Law), which establishes legal framework economic relations in the field of electric power industry (Article 1), i.e. sets features legal regulation relations regulated by civil law.
<2>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 03/31/2003. N 13. Art. 1177.The federal law consolidated the main provisions of the reform of the industry, including the division of types of activities in the electric power industry into competitive and non-competitive, and established the features of the legal regulation of the activities of a legal entity depending on the type of electric power facilities that it uses in its business activities in this industry.
During the reform process, a large number of power industry entities were created, including generating companies, technological and commercial infrastructure organizations, and energy sales companies.
Under the electric power industry, the Federal Law understands persons engaged in activities in the electric power industry, including the production of electric and thermal energy, the supply (sale) of electric energy, the energy supply to consumers, the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy, operational dispatch management in the electric power industry, the sale of electric energy, the organization of the purchase and sale of electric energy.
This article will focus on grid organizations as subjects of the electric power industry. As of 2011, there are more than 2,500 network organizations operating in Russia (these are only those legal entities who applied to the regulatory body for setting a tariff for electricity transmission services)<3>.
<3>We are ready to consider any responsible proposals // Kommersant. 08/26/2011. N 158. S. 10.Grid organizations The federal law classifies them as infrastructure organizations.
Under the infrastructure it is customary to understand the totality of industries, enterprises and organizations included in these industries, their types of activities, designed to provide, create conditions for the normal functioning of the production and circulation of goods, as well as the life of people ...<4>.
<4>Raizberg B.A., Lozovsky L.Sh., Starodubtseva E.B. Modern economic dictionary. M.: INFRA-M, 2006 (SPS "ConsultantPlus").Part of the subjects of the electric power industry are referred by federal law to subjects of commercial or technological infrastructure. Organizations of the commercial infrastructure of the wholesale market include the non-profit partnership "Market Council", which is the organizer of the wholesale market for electricity and capacity, the commercial operator of the wholesale market, which provides services for organizing wholesale trade electricity, capacity and other goods and services admitted to circulation on the wholesale market, as well as other commercial infrastructure organizations.
Technological infrastructure organizations include grid organizations that provide services for the transmission of electrical energy (capacity) and technological connection: JSC FGC UES - an organization for managing a unified national (all-Russian) electric grid (hereinafter referred to as UNEG) and territorial grid organizations<5>(hereinafter referred to as TCO), as well as OAO SO UES, which provides services for operational dispatch control to electric power industry entities and consumers of electric energy.
<5>In turn, the management of a number of major regional TCOs carries out OJSC "Holding of Interregional Distribution Grid Companies", formed on 07/01/2008 on the day of the liquidation of RAO UES of Russia. The state owns 53.7% of the shares of JSC KhMRSK. In turn, JSC KhMRSK owns 51 - 100% of the shares of regional TSO - IDGC. Combines most of the assets of the distribution electric grid complex of Russia (substations and networks with a voltage of 0.4 - 220 kV), with the exception of the Far East and networks of regional energy systems, do not enter former members of RAO "UES" The main characteristics of the holding:- 591 billion kWh- the volume of electricity transmitted through the holding's networks in 2010 (about 59% of Russian consumption);
- 559.5 billion rubles- consolidated revenue under IFRS in 2010;
- 34 billion rubles - net profit in 2010 year.
According to: We are ready to consider any responsible proposals // Kommersant. 08/26/2011. No. 158, p. 10; The government will spread the net for investors // Kommersant. 03/14/2011. No. 42/P.
In addition, the legislator refers to the facilities used by grid organizations in the course of their business activities as technological infrastructure - the basis for the functioning of the electric power industry. According to paragraph 1 of Art. 5 of the Federal Law, the technological basis for the functioning of the electric power industry is the UNEG, territorial distribution networks through which electric energy is transmitted, and one system operational dispatch control.
The main principle of using the technological infrastructure of the electric power industry by the subjects of the wholesale market is to provide the most effective organization economic relations in the wholesale market.
The interaction of wholesale and (or) retail market entities with the UNEG and (or) TCO management organization is carried out in accordance with the Rules for non-discriminatory access to electric power transmission services and the provision of these services, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2004 N 861<6>, Rules of the wholesale market of electric energy and capacity, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2010 N 1172<7>, as well as the Basic Provisions for the Functioning of Retail Electricity Markets, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 31, 2006 N 530<8>.
<6>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 12/27/2004. No. 52 (part 2). Art. 5525.<7>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 04/04/2011. N 14. Art. 1916.
<8>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 09/11/2006. N 37. Art. 3876.
IN currently The federal law does not disclose the concept of "infrastructural organization" and does not establish the specifics of the legal regulation of the activities of such organizations. Assignment or non-assignment of a legal entity to an infrastructure organization does not change the legal regulation of the activities of this entity. At the same time, the development of the UNEG and TSO power grid facilities is a priority task for grid organizations and the investment policy of the state as a whole. So, for example, in accordance with paragraph 3 of Art. 29 of the Federal Law, the goals of the state investment policy in the development of the UNEG are to increase the efficiency of the electric power industry, eliminate technological restrictions on the flow of electric energy and increase the capacity of electric networks to ensure the output of power by power plants. For these purposes, the state regulates the investment activities of the UNEG management organization.
The first legal concept of "network organization"<9>was enshrined in the Rules for non-discriminatory access to services for the transmission of electrical energy and the provision of these services, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2004 N 861 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules).
<9>Until the beginning of 2003, an attempt was made in legal acts to introduce the concept of an electric grid organization into the legal field. So, in particular, in accordance with paragraph 3 of the Rules for the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy, approved by the Decree of the FEC of the Russian Federation of September 11, 1998 N 36/3, "power company"- a legal entity, regardless of its organizational and legal form, owning or on another legal basis electrical networks and (or) electrical energy conversion devices, carrying out economic activity for the provision of comprehensive services related to the use of electrical networks and (or) devices for converting electrical energy. Considering that the text of the Decree was not officially published and the Decree of the FEC of the Russian Federation of May 14, 2003 N 37-e / 15 declared the above Decree invalid, in this article we will not characterize this concept.Under the network organizations in the Decree were understood commercial organizations, main activity which is the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy through electric networks, as well as the implementation of measures for technological connection.
This concept, due to its incorrectness, was changed by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of March 21, 2007 N 168<10>. The incorrectness of the concept was revealed during the enforcement of the norms of the Rules. In particular, clause 3 of the Rules provides for ensuring equal conditions for the provision of services to their consumers, regardless of the organizational and legal form and legal relations with the person providing these services. Thus, the norms of the Rules are aimed at implementing Art. 426 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation and paragraph 2 of Art. 26 of the Federal Law and fix general principles and the procedure for ensuring non-discriminatory access to electricity transmission services, as well as the provision of these services, including preventing the grid organization from refusing to conclude a public contract if it is possible to provide the consumer with the relevant services (electricity transmission and technological connection).
<10>Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of March 21, 2007 N 168 "On Amendments to Certain Decrees of the Government of the Russian Federation on Electricity Issues" was published in the Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation, April 2, 2007, N 14, art. 1687.At the same time, the previously existing concept excluded the application of the rules of the Rules to such organizations whose main activity was not the provision of services or technological connection, but, for example, the production of paper, metal, etc., but at the same time, the organization legally owned power grid facilities. Abuse, as a rule, was expressed in the evasion of the conclusion of an agreement on the implementation of technological connection by organizations that own electric grid facilities, while the main activity of which was transmission or technological connection.
At present, according to clause 2 of the Rules, grid organizations are organizations that own, on the basis of ownership or on another basis established by federal laws, electric grid facilities, with the use of which such organizations provide services for the transmission of electric energy and carry out, in the prescribed manner, the technological connection of power receiving devices (power installations) of legal and individuals to electric networks, as well as exercising the right to conclude contracts for the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy using electric grid facilities owned by other owners and other legal owners and included in the UNEG.
Based on the above concept, the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry contains the following characteristics of a subject of the electric power industry, in the presence of which a person can be recognized as a grid organization.
First sign. A network organization is an organization. According to paragraph 1 of Art. 2 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation<11>(hereinafter referred to as the Civil Code of the Russian Federation) the participants in relations regulated by civil law are citizens and legal entities. Under the legal entity of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation is understood an organization that owns, manages or manages separate property and is liable for its obligations with this property, can acquire and exercise property and personal non-property rights on its own behalf, bear obligations, be a plaintiff and defendant in court (Article 48 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
<11>Civil Code of the Russian Federation of November 30, 1994 N 51-FZ // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 12/05/1994. N 32. Art. 3301.Based on the concept of "network organization" disclosed in the Rules, only a legal entity can be a network organization. Citizens (individuals carrying out entrepreneurial activity) cannot be recognized as a network organization. At the same time, according to paragraph 1 of Art. 22 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, no one can be limited in legal capacity and capacity otherwise than in cases and in the manner established by law. Civil rights may be limited on the basis of a federal law and only to the extent necessary to protect the foundations of the constitutional order, morality, health, rights and legitimate interests of others, to ensure the defense of the country and the security of the state (paragraph 2, clause 2, article 1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). The federal law does not directly establish the objectives of the restriction, and the restriction itself is clearly legal and technical<12>not expressed.
<12>Legal technique in a broad sense can be defined as a set of means and methods by which the goals outlined or pursued by the authorities of civil society fit into the mainstream of legal norms and are achieved through the effective implementation of these norms. See: Sandevuar P. Introduction to law. M., 1994. S. 135.In accordance with the legal position of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, consistently stated in the Resolutions of May 14, 1999 N 8-P, of July 15, 1999 N 11-P, of May 27, 2003 N 9-P, of November 14, 2005 N 10-P, of May 27, 2008 N 8-P, of July 13, 2010 N 15-P, inaccuracy, vagueness and uncertainty of the law give rise to the possibility of ambiguous interpretation and, therefore, its arbitrary application, which contradicts the constitutional principles of equality and justice, from which the requirement of certainty, clarity, unambiguity of legal norms and their consistency in the system of current legal regulation follows; otherwise, there may be conflicting law enforcement practices that weaken safeguards state protection rights, freedoms and legitimate interests.
Thus, from the point of view of legal technique in terms of establishing restrictions, it is necessary to clarify the norms of the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry.
Second sign. Grid organization - an organization that owns by the right of ownership or on another basis established by federal laws the objects of the electric grid economy. The second sign of a network organization is based on the principle of title ownership<13>legal entity by electric grid facilities. Under the power grid facilities st. 3 of the Federal Law understands power lines, transformer and other substations, distribution points and other equipment designed to provide electrical connections and carry out the transmission of electrical energy. The legislation of the Russian Federation does not contain a general rule limiting the turnover of electric grid facilities.
<13>Title ownership is possession of a thing based on some right (legal basis or title) arising from the relevant legal fact, for example, the right of ownership based on a contract for the sale of a thing or on its transfer by inheritance. In contrast, titleless (actual) ownership is not based on any legal basis, although, under the conditions established by law, it may also entail certain legal consequences // Civil law: In 2 volumes. Vol. I: Textbook / Ans. ed. prof. E.A. Sukhanov. 2nd ed., revised. and additional M.: Publishing house "BEK", 2003. S. 493.Third sign. A legal entity can be attributed to a grid organization if it carries out the following types of activities using power grid facilities:
- provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy;
- implementation in accordance with the established procedure of technological connection of power receiving devices (power plants) of legal entities and individuals.
Prior to the adoption of the Federal Law, a by-law normative legal act delimited the concept of "transmission of electrical energy" from the concept of "distribution of electrical energy"<14>.
<14>See: The main directions of reforming the electric power industry of the Russian Federation, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of July 11, 2001 N 526 (Collected Legislation of the Russian Federation. 16.07.2001. N 29. Art. 3032).At present, the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry does not contain the above delimitation, and under the services for the transmission of electric energy, the Federal Law understands a set of organizational and technologically related actions, including operational and technological management, ensuring the transmission of electric energy through the technical devices of electric networks in accordance with mandatory requirements(Article 3 of the Federal Law).
According to paragraph 2 of Art. 26 of the Federal Law, the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy is carried out on the basis of an agreement paid provision services. The contract for the provision of these services is public <15>.
<15>In accordance with paragraph 1 of Art. 426 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, a public contract is a contract concluded by a commercial organization and establishing its obligations to sell goods, perform work or provide services that such an organization, by the nature of its activities, must carry out in relation to everyone who applies to it ( retail, transportation by public transport, communication services, energy supply, medical, hotel service and so on.).The activities for the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy, carried out by grid organizations, as well as the specified activities of owners or other legal owners of electric grid facilities, are carried out under conditions of natural monopoly and are regulated in accordance with the legislation on natural monopolies, the Federal Law "On the Electric Power Industry" and other federal laws.
Article 4 of the Federal Law of August 17, 1995 N 147-FZ "On Natural Monopolies"<16>classifies the activity on the transmission of electric energy to natural monopoly activities.
<16>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 08/21/1995. N 34. Art. 3426.Production under natural monopoly has an important technological feature, defining it economic efficiency: it is characterized by a significant reduction in costs per unit of goods (products) as volumes increase. This is usually the result of significant economies of scale and high fixed costs. In connection with such a cost structure, it is not the competition of several producers that turns out to be more effective, as in other industries, but the absence of competition and the monopoly of one commodity producer. main feature natural monopoly lies in the fact that the satisfaction of demand in a given market under monopoly conditions is more efficient than under competitive conditions.<17>.
<17>Avilov G.E., Belov V.E., Klein N.I., Kotov S.F., Pavlova O.K., Razgulyaev Yu.A., Tsukanova N.Sh. Commentary on the Federal Law "On Natural Monopolies" // Legislation and Economics. N 19-20(137-138)/96. S. 6.In accordance with the Federal Law "On Natural Monopolies", the prevailing method of administrative and legal regulation and control applied to subjects of natural monopolies is price regulation, carried out by setting tariffs or their ceiling levels for certain types products (services), the list of which is established by law<18>.
<18>Erina E.N. Problems of price regulation in relation to subjects of natural monopolies of the fuel and energy complex // Legislation and Economics. 2008. No. 4.One of essential functions bodies regulating natural monopolies is the formation and maintenance of the register of subjects of natural monopolies. The decision to introduce regulation is the basis for including a subject of natural monopoly in the register. The inclusion of a subject of natural monopoly in the register does not depend on its market share and on whether it allows violations of the law. The register includes only those economic entities that are engaged in the production (sale) of goods under conditions of natural monopoly.
In addition to the above type of activity carried out in accordance with the legislation on natural monopolies, a grid organization is obliged to carry out measures for the technological connection of newly commissioned, newly built, expanding its previously connected capacity and reconstructed power receiving devices to its electric networks (hereinafter referred to as technological connection) in relation to any person who has applied to it, subject to its compliance with the Rules for the technological connection of power receiving devices of consumers of electric energy, electric power production facilities, as well as electric grid facilities belonging to the grid. organizations and other persons, to electric networks, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2004 N 861 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules for Technological Connection), and the availability of technical feasibility of technological connection.
According to par. 2 p. 1 art. 26 of the Federal Law, technological connection is carried out on the basis of an agreement on the implementation of technological connection to electric grid facilities, concluded by the grid organization and the person who applied to it. This agreement is public.
It should be noted that the owner (not being a grid organization) of a power receiving device or electric power facilities previously technologically connected in the proper manner, in agreement with the grid organization, has the right to connect a third party (another owner of the electric power facility) to its networks, subject to the previously issued technical conditions. In this case, between the specified owner of the power receiving device and a third party, an agreement is concluded on the implementation of technological connection, the fee for which is established in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry.
Fourth sign. A grid organization is an organization exercising the right to conclude contracts for the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy using electric grid facilities owned by other owners and other legal owners that are members of the UNEG.
This feature is typical for the UNEG management organization. At present, more than 60 legal entities are the owners of electric grid facilities, which by their parameters refer to UNEG facilities. The total number of such objects owned by other owners is more than 400. As a rule, we are talking on power grid facilities of entities that were not part of the RAO UES of Russia holding company, so the consolidation of such facilities through centralized corporate procedures could not be carried out.
Federal law in order to ensure the security of the Russian Federation, protect the rights and legitimate interests of legal entities and individuals, ensure the unity of the economic space in the field of electricity circulation limited the owners or other legal owners of power grid facilities included in the UNEG, in exercising their rights in part:
conclusion of contracts for the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy using the power grid facilities included in the UNEG, and determination of the terms of these contracts;
use (decommissioning) of these facilities without the consent of the UNEG management organization (clause 2, article 7 of the Federal Law).
The rights of owners and other legal owners of electric grid facilities included in the UNEG, limited by the Federal Law, are exercised by the UNEG management organization.
The UNEG management organization concludes agreements with other owners or other legal owners of electric grid facilities included in the UNEG that determine the procedure for using these facilities.
The conclusion of such agreements is obligatory for owners or other legal owners of electric grid facilities included in the UNEG.
The above four signs of a grid organization are specified in the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry. In this article, we want to draw attention to other signs that characterize the legal regulation of the activities of grid organizations or distinguish their regulation from other participants in legal relations in the electric power industry.
The legal regulation of the activities of grid organizations must be distinguished from the legal regulation of the activities of other owners of electric grid facilities. Grid organizations are professional participants in the electricity and capacity markets, provide services for the transmission of electricity on an ongoing basis and carry out activities for technological connection. The contracts on the basis of which the above services are provided are public, and network organizations are not entitled to refuse to conclude them or give preference to certain potential consumers.<19>.
<19>So, in the Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of 06.06.2002 N 115-O it is indicated that the refusal of the organization to conclude a public contract if it is possible to provide the consumer with appropriate services is not allowed, and in case of avoiding in such a case from concluding a public contract, the other party has the right to apply to the court with a demand for compulsion to conclude a contract and for compensation for losses caused by an unreasonable refusal to conclude it (paragraph 3 of Article 426 and paragraph 4 of Article 445 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).Other owners of power grid facilities, as a rule, created power grid facilities to meet their own production needs. Forcing such owners to enter into mandatory contracts with any person who applied would be a restriction of rights and a violation of the fundamental principle of civil law - freedom of contract (clause 1, article 1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, article 421 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). At the same time, taking into account the specifics of building the UES of Russia, energy supply schemes settlements and continuity of the process of production, transmission and consumption of social significant product- Electricity and capacity The legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry imposes certain restrictions on other owners of electric grid facilities.
The federal law provides that another owner of electric grid facilities to which power receiving devices or electric power facilities are technologically connected in the proper manner shall not have the right to prevent the transmission of electric energy to said devices or objects and (or) from said devices or objects, including the conclusion of contracts for the sale and purchase of electric energy, energy supply contracts, contracts for the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy in relation to these devices or objects.
So, for example, if power receiving devices of the consumer electrical energy are connected to the electric grids of the grid organization through:
(1) power plants of electricity producers;
(2) electric grid facilities of entities that do not provide electric power transmission services; or
(3) ownerless power grid facilities that are directly connected to the networks of grid organizations,
such a consumer enters into an agreement for the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy from that network organization, to the networks of which power plants of electric energy producers, ownerless electric grid facilities or power receiving devices (power grid facilities) of persons who do not provide electric power transmission services, to which its power receiving device is directly connected, are connected.
This institution has the name of indirect connection, established by the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry and aimed at protecting the rights of an indefinite circle of persons to freely gain access to a socially significant object of civil law - electricity and power for the purpose of its consumption.
The specified owners and other legal owners of electric grid facilities through which the consumer's power receiving device is indirectly connected to the electric grids of the grid organization are entitled to provide services for the transmission of electric energy using the electric grid facilities belonging to them after the establishment of a tariff for electric energy transmission services for them.
On the grounds of: 1) title ownership of electric grid facilities that are or are not included in the UNEG; 2) the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy in the wholesale or retail markets, grid organizations can be divided into the UNEG management organization and TSO.
These criteria for distinguishing grid organizations are currently conditional, since it is not uncommon for a UNEG management organization to provide services to retail market entities and, conversely, a TSO provides services for the transmission of electricity to wholesale market entities. In addition, the Federal Law allows until January 1, 2014 for the UNEG management organization to lease electric grid facilities to TSOs in agreement with the authorized federal executive authorities.<20>.
<20>See: Rules for coordinating the transfer of electric grid facilities included in the unified national (all-Russian) electric grid for lease to territorial grid organizations, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2010 N 1173 // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 06/06/2011. N 23. Art. 3316.At the same time, it must be emphasized that the UNEG is the main part of the Unified Energy System of Russia and includes a system of main power transmission lines that unite most regions of the country, and is one of the elements of guaranteeing the integrity of the state<21>.
<21>Chapter II. Directions for reforming the electric power industry, section 2. Reforming the electric power industry, subsection "Creation of a federal grid company" of the Main directions for reforming the electric power industry of the Russian Federation, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of July 11, 2001 N 526.In accordance with Art. 7 of the Federal Law, the UNEG is a complex of electric networks and other objects of the electric grid economy, owned by the right of ownership or on another basis provided for by federal laws to the subjects of the electric power industry and ensuring a stable supply of electric energy to consumers, the functioning of the wholesale market, as well as the parallel operation of the Russian electric power system and the electric power systems of foreign states.
The criteria for classifying electric grid facilities as part of the UNEG are approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of January 26, 2006 N 41<22>. The conditions for referring electric grid facilities to the UNEG and the procedure for maintaining the register of electric grid facilities included in the UNEG are approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of October 28, 2003 N 648.
<22>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 01/30/2006. N 5. Art. 556.However, one exception is made in the legislation of the Russian Federation: the complex of electric networks and other electric grid facilities of public railway transport does not belong to the UNEG. Open Joint Stock Company "Russian railways"disposes of the specified objects independently, taking into account the restrictions established by the Federal Law of February 27, 2003 N 29-ФЗ "On the Peculiarities of Management and Disposition of Railway Transport Property"<23>.
<23>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 03.03.2003. N 9. Art. 805.In order to preserve and strengthen the UNEG, ensure the unity technological management and implementation public policy in the electric power industry, an organization was created to manage the UNEG.
In accordance with paragraph 3 of the Regulations on the attribution of electric grid facilities to the UNEG and on the maintenance of the register of electric grid facilities included in the UNEG, approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of October 28, 2003 N 648, the Federal Grid Company of the Unified Energy System, an open joint-stock company, was named the UNEG management organization<24>.
<24>The Russian Federation owns 79.48% of the shares of JSC FGC UES. The market capitalization of JSC FGC UES as of December 31, 2010 is 452 billion rubles. Currently, JSC FGC UES owns the main part of the UNEG facilities:- number of substations - 797;
- total power of transformers 35 - 750 kV - 305 459 MVA;
- total length of networks - 121.096 thousand km;
- electricity supply - 466 billion kWh.
The legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry establishes that the share of participation of the Russian Federation in authorized capital management organization of the UNEG upon completion of the reform of RAO UES of Russia should be at least 75 percent plus one voting share.
The creation of an organization for the management of the UNEG, according to the reformers, should allow:
to strengthen the integrating role of the Unified Energy System of Russia and ensure the interaction of electricity producers and consumers in the competitive wholesale electricity market;
ensure direct connection of all regions of Russia to the UNEG;
guarantee equal access for sellers and buyers to the wholesale electricity market;
carry out effective state regulation of electricity transmission tariffs;
improve the energy security of the state;
promote the implementation of an effective state foreign economic policy in the field of electric power industry.
JSC FGC UES, as a UNEG management organization, performs one of important tasks which are intended to be solved by civil legislation, since the reliable operation and development of UNEG facilities ensure the unity of the economic space on the territory of the Russian Federation.
The UNEG management organization provides, on a reimbursable contractual basis, services for the transmission of electric energy through the UNEG to wholesale market entities, as well as to other persons owning power facilities or on other grounds provided for by federal laws, technologically connected in the prescribed manner to the UNEG.
The concept of "territorial network organization" is disclosed in Art. 3 of the Federal Law, according to which a territorial grid organization is a commercial organization that provides services for the transmission of electrical energy using power grid facilities that are not related to the UNEG. Based on the definition of TCO, we can conclude that this is not just an organization, but a commercial organization. In accordance with Art. 50 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, legal entities can be organizations that pursue profit making as the main goal of their activities (commercial organizations) or do not have profit making as such a goal and do not distribute the profits received among participants (non-profit organizations). Legal entities that are commercial organizations can be created in the form business partnerships and societies production cooperatives, state and municipal unitary enterprises.
Thus, on the one hand, the differentiation of grid organizations into an organization for the management of the UNEG and into territorial grid organizations is based on the second sign of the legal concept of a grid organization by the title of ownership of electric grid facilities and their differentiation into objects related to the UNEG and objects not related to the UNEG. On the other hand, there is a unifying feature: network organizations are commercial organizations. In addition to the above features of grid organizations (their legal definition and classification by the legislation as infrastructure organizations), it is necessary to pay attention to two more features that are based on the conceptual provisions of the Federal Law and were the basis for reforming the electric power industry of the Russian Federation.
It's about rules and regulations.<25>, which, in turn, contribute to the implementation of the differentiation of subjects of the electric power industry into competitive ones and those carrying out a natural monopoly type of activity (a field of economic relations in which competition is impossible).
<25>Prohibiting norm - a norm that establishes the obligation of the subject to refrain from committing actions of a certain kind (for example, not to inform strangers about the fact of adoption; not to adopt laws that violate human rights and freedoms). See: Alekseev S.S. Law: ABC - Theory - Philosophy: An Experience of Comprehensive Research. M.: Statut, 1999. S. 64.In particular, there are two restrictions. The first is established in paragraph 4 of Art. 8 and in paragraph 1 of Art. 41 of the Federal Law, according to which:
the UNEG management organization is prohibited from engaging in activities for the purchase and sale of electrical energy and capacity (with the exception of the purchase of electrical energy (capacity) carried out for its own (economic) needs; the purchase of electrical energy (capacity) carried out in order to compensate for losses in electrical networks and technological support for the joint operation of the Russian electrical energy system and the electrical energy systems of foreign states, as well as in cases and in the manner determined by the Government of the Russian Federation, when performing the functions of a supplier of last resort);
territorial grid organizations are prohibited from engaging in activities for the purchase and sale of electrical energy (with the exception of the purchase by territorial grid organizations of electrical energy for the purpose of compensating for losses in electrical networks), as well as in cases and in the manner determined by the Government of the Russian Federation, when performing the functions of a supplier of last resort.
In order to ensure the implementation of these requirements, the legislation of the Russian Federation on the electric power industry from April 1, 2006 does not allow the possibility of simultaneously owning property or on another basis provided for by federal laws, property directly used in the implementation of activities for the transmission of electric energy and operational dispatch control in the electric power industry, and property directly used in the implementation of activities for the production and purchase and sale of electric energy.
In addition, par. 5 st. 4 of the Federal Law of March 26, 2003 N 36-FZ "On the peculiarities of the functioning of the electric power industry in the transition period and on the introduction of amendments to certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation and the invalidation of certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation in connection with the adoption of the Federal Law "On the electric power industry"<26>establishes that organizations created during the reorganization of OAO RAO UES of Russia, its subsidiaries and affiliates, are not entitled to simultaneously own power grid facilities related to the UNEG and power grid facilities that are not related to the UNEG.
<26>Collection of legislation of the Russian Federation. 03/31/2003. N 13. Art. 1178.One more, very specific, technological sign of a network organization can be pointed out. As is known, in the process of transmission of electrical energy through the objects of the electric grid economy, natural decline transmitted energy, the so-called losses.
In accordance with paragraph 51 of the Rules, grid organizations are obliged to pay the cost of actual losses of electrical energy that have arisen in their network facilities, minus the cost of losses taken into account in prices (tariffs) for electrical energy in the wholesale market.
The amount of actual losses of electrical energy in electrical networks is determined as the difference between the volume of electrical energy supplied to the electrical network from other networks or from electrical energy producers and the volume of electrical energy consumed by power receiving devices connected to this network, as well as transferred to other network organizations.
Consumers of services, with the exception of electricity producers, are obliged to pay as part of the tariff for electric energy transmission services the standard losses arising from the transmission of electric energy through the network by the network organization with which the relevant persons have concluded an agreement, with the exception of losses included in the price (tariff) of electric energy, in order to avoid their double counting.
Standards for technological losses are established by the authorized federal executive body in accordance with the rules and methodology for calculating standard technological losses of electricity in electric networks<27>.
<27>Instructions on the organization in the Ministry of Energy of the Russian Federation of work on the calculation and justification of the standards for technological losses of electricity during its transmission through electric networks, approved by Order of the Ministry of Energy of Russia dated December 30, 2008 N 326 // Bulletin of normative acts of federal executive authorities. 20.04.2009. N 16.The standards for losses of electrical energy in electrical networks are established in relation to the totality of power transmission lines and other objects of the electrical grid economy owned by the relevant grid organization, taking into account the differentiation by voltage levels of the networks when setting tariffs for services for the transmission of electrical energy.
Based on the foregoing, we can propose the following concept of a grid organization in the Russian electric power industry as a subject of civil law.
A grid organization is a legal entity that is a commercial organization with legal capacity limited by law, entered in the register of subjects of natural monopolies in accordance with the procedure established by law and providing services on a reimbursable basis for the transmission of electric energy and (or) technological connection to the electric grid facilities of the grid organization of electric power facilities and (or) power receiving devices, the price (tariffs, fees) for which, in accordance with the legislation, is established and (or) regulated by authorized government bodies, and the nature of the activities of such an organization obliges it to provide these services in relation to everyone who applies to it.
Subjects of the electric power industry
Art. 3 of the Federal Law "On the Electric Power Industry" approximate list of such entities: subjects of the electric power industry - persons engaged in activities in the field of electric power industry, including the production of electrical, thermal energy and power, the purchase and sale of electrical energy and power, the supply of consumers, the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy, operational dispatch control in the electric power industry, the sale of electrical energy (capacity), the organization of the purchase and sale of electrical energy and power.
From this definition it follows that consumers are not included in the circle of subjects of the electric power industry, however, they are subjects of the wholesale and retail markets of electric energy.
Among the subjects of the electric power industry, the organization for managing the Unified National Electric Grid, the system operator, the administrator of the trading system, and generating companies stand out. The organization for managing the Unified National Electric Grid is JSC Federal Grid Company.
A system operator is a specialized organization that solely carries out centralized operational dispatch control within the Unified Energy System of Russia (also JSC).
Trading system administrator - non-profit organization Market Council. This is an analogue of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation, since the Market Council is empowered to develop regulations and so on.
Generating companies - producers of electrical energy; these are the owners or other legal owners of HPPs, NPPs, TPPs. The activities of generating companies are carried out on the basis of a large number by-laws (there are few laws, for example, the Federal Law "On the Features of the Management and Disposition of Property and Shares of Organizations Operating in the Field of the Use of Atomic Energy").
In the field of electric power industry, in addition to the subjects of the electric power industry, the legislator also indicates the subjects of operational dispatch control, subjects of the wholesale market, subjects of retail markets. At the same time, a simple addition of these entities does not give a list of entities in the electric power industry.
Property objects directly used in the process of production, transmission of electric energy, operational dispatch control and sale of electric energy, including electric grid facilities.
Regulations on this point are contradictory: cf. the regulation on the attribution of electric grid facilities to the Unified National Electric Grid and on the maintenance of registers of these objects and the provision on the criteria for attributing electric grid facilities to the Unified National Electric Grid.
Unified Energy system Russia ( ENS) - a set of production and other property objects of the electric power industry connected by a single process of production (including production in the mode of combined generation of electric and thermal energy) and transmission of electric energy (capacity) in the conditions of centralized operational dispatch control in the electric power industry;
Subjects of the electric power industry- persons carrying out activities in the field of electric power industry, including the production of electric and thermal energy, the supply (sale) of electric energy (capacity), energy supply to consumers, the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy, operational dispatch management in the electric power industry, the sale of electric energy, the organization of the purchase and sale of electric energy.
Consumers electrical and thermal energy - persons acquiring electrical and thermal energy for own household and (or) industrial needs in the wholesale or retail markets of electric energy and capacity.
wholesale electrical market energy (capacity) (hereinafter - the wholesale market) - the sphere of circulation of a special product - electric energy (capacity) within the framework of the Unified Energy System of Russia within the boundaries of the single economic space of the Russian Federation with the participation of large producers and major buyers electric energy (capacity) that have received the status of a wholesale market entity and operate on the basis of the wholesale market rules approved by the Government of the Russian Federation. The criteria for classifying producers and buyers of electrical energy as major producers and major buyers are established by the Government of the Russian Federation;
Wholesale market entities are legal entities that have received statutory order the right to participate in relations related to the circulation of electricity in the wholesale market, in accordance with the rules of the wholesale market.
Wholesale market zone - a territory determined by the Government of the Russian Federation and within whose boundaries the wholesale market equilibrium price is formed in the manner prescribed by the wholesale market rules (hereinafter referred to as the wholesale market price zone).
Retail markets of electrical energy - the sphere of circulation of electrical energy outside the wholesale market with the participation of consumers of electrical energy.
Energy supply organization. An organization that combines the activity of buying and selling electrical energy with the activity of its transmission.
Energy sales organizations- organizations engaged in the sale of produced or purchased electric energy to other persons as their main activity.
A bilateral contract for the purchase and sale of electrical energy is an agreement in accordance with which the supplier undertakes to supply the buyer with electrical energy in a certain quantity and quality determined by the relevant technical regulations and other mandatory requirements, and the buyer undertakes to accept and pay for electrical energy on the terms of the contract concluded in accordance with the rules of the wholesale market and the basic provisions of the operation of retail markets.
(OJSC Chuvash Energy Retail Company)
Guaranteed supplier of electrical energy. A commercial organization that is obliged, in accordance with the legislation on the electric power industry or voluntarily assumed obligations, to conclude an agreement for the purchase and sale of electrical energy with any consumer who has applied to him or with a person acting on behalf and in the interests of the consumer and wishing to purchase electrical energy. Suppliers of last resort supply electric energy to buyers of electric energy in the territory of their area of activity according to public contracts supply or purchase and sale (supply) of electrical energy.
For the proper execution of power supply contracts, the guaranteeing supplier shall regulate the relations related to the operational dispatch management in relation to the supply points in the retail market of electricity buyers serviced by this guaranteeing supplier, and also regulate the relations related to the transmission of electrical energy by concluding contracts for the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy with grid organizations, to the electric networks of which the corresponding power receiving devices are connected.
Electricity transmission services- a set of organizationally and technologically related actions that ensure the transmission of electrical energy (power) through the technical devices of electrical networks in accordance with technical regulations;
Power grid facilities- power lines, transformer and other substations, distribution points and other equipment designed to provide electrical connections and transfer electrical energy (power). Unified National (All-Russian) Electric Grid ENS includes:
1) power lines (overhead and cable), the design rated voltage class of which is 330 kilovolts and above;
2) power lines, the design rated voltage class of which is 220 kilovolts:
Providing the issuance of energy power to the network power stations subjects of the federal (all-Russian) wholesale electricity (capacity) market;
Suppliers of electrical energy (capacity) to the specified market;
Providing connection and parallel operation of energy systems of various subjects of the Russian Federation;
Ensuring the issuance of energy power to the nodes of the electrical load with an attached transformer power of at least 125 megavolt-amperes;
Directly providing connection of the listed power lines, including power lines and other equipment specified in Appendix No. 2 to the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of August 15, 1992 No. 923;
3) power lines crossing the state border of the Russian Federation;
4) transformer and other substations connected to the power lines listed in subparagraphs 1-3, as well as technological equipment located on them, with the exception of switchgears of power plants - subjects of the federal (all-Russian) wholesale market of electric energy (capacity), included in Property Complex specified stations;
5) a complex of equipment and production and technological facilities intended for Maintenance and operation of the said electric grid facilities;
systems and means of control of the specified electric grid facilities.
(Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 21, 2001 No. 881 "On the criteria for classifying main power transmission lines and electric grid facilities as a single national (all-Russian) electric grid") Territorial grid organization;
Operational dispatch control services in the electric power industry - a set of measures for centralized control of technological modes of operation technical devices power plants, electrical networks and power receiving equipment of electrical energy consumers with a controlled load, carried out in order to ensure reliable power supply and quality of electrical energy that comply with technical regulations and other mandatory requirements.
Consumers of electrical energy with controlled load- a category of consumers of electrical energy that, due to the modes of operation (consumption of electrical energy), affect the quality of electrical energy, the reliability of the operation of the Unified Energy System of Russia and, in this regard, provide services on a paid contractual basis to ensure the withdrawal of the Unified Energy System of Russia from emergencies. These consumers may also provide other services agreed with them on the terms of the contract.
Generation- Producer of electrical energy. The owner or other legal owner of generating equipment, for which the production and sale of electrical energy is the main activity:
1. Territorial generating companies (TGC-5)
3. JSC Rus Hydro
4. OJSC Atomenergo
5. Independent manufacturers.
open joint-stock companies created as a result of reforming AO-energos on the basis of generating assets.
Combined generation of electrical and thermal energy- the mode of operation of thermal power plants, in which the production of electrical energy is directly related to the simultaneous production of thermal energy.
Last resort supplier of electrical energy (hereinafter referred to as the supplier of last resort) is a commercial organization obliged, in accordance with this Federal Law or voluntarily assumed obligations, to conclude a contract for the purchase and sale of electrical energy with any consumer who applied to him or with a person acting on behalf and in the interests of the consumer and wishing to purchase electrical energy.
System Operator Unified Energy System of Russia. Dispatch center of the System Operator of the Unified Energy System in the organizational and legal form of a branch, which manages the operating modes on a part of the territory of the UES of Russia under the supervision of superior dispatch centers of the System Operator of the Unified Energy System (Chuvash branch of the RDU);
Trading system administrator. Organization in the form non-profit partnership, the main purpose of which is to provide services for the organization of trade in the wholesale electricity (capacity) market, as well as financial settlements for the supplied electricity and services provided to participants in the wholesale market, ensuring equal conditions for all participants in the wholesale electricity market, protecting the interests of suppliers and buyers of electricity, increasing the efficiency of production and consumption of electricity.
The subjects of the electric power industry in the territory of the Chuvash Republic are electric generating, electric grid companies, including those of municipal ownership, dispatching and sales companies.
Chuvash branch "T +". The Chuvash branch of PJSC "T +" is the basis of the energy complex of the republic, providing:
1. Basic generation of electrical energy to supply consumers throughout the country in annual volumes over 2200 million kWh;
2. Heat supply of the largest cities of the republic (CHP-3 - almost 100% of the residential and social sectors of the city of Novocheboksarsk, and CHPP-2 - about 50% of the city of Cheboksary;
4. Steady passage of autumn-winter power system load peaks;
5. Tariff preferences for consumers of thermal energy.
The Chuvash branch of T+ is not only the basis for sustainable heat supply to urban consumers, but also ensures a reduction in consumption natural gas with the introduced technological and emergency restrictions on gas supplies to the republic by maintaining the necessary reserves of fuel oil. At the same time, by purchasing over 435 million m3 of natural gas at commercial prices and providing reserves of fuel oil in the prescribed volumes, it releases thermal energy at tariffs significantly lower than the average tariffs for gas boilers of the republic. The company includes three thermal and one wind power plants. Table 3.1 shows the values of the installed, available and operating capacities of the branch's power plants. The total installed capacity of power plants is 852.2 MW.
Table 1
The decrease in the efficiency of thermal plants is determined by:
Insufficient steam consumption from turbine extractions at Cheboksarskaya CHPP-2 and Novocheboksarskaya CHPP-3 and underutilization of capacities at thermal power plants;
Non-compliance of generating capacities with the existing consumption of heat and electric energy by enterprises of the republic;
Insufficient performance auxiliary equipment thermal power plants (circulation pumps, cooling towers);
aging core production assets;
Non-compliance of technological modes with equipment parameters;
The lack of a single space for dispatching the distribution and accounting of electrical energy;
The presence in the tariffs for thermal energy of cross-subsidization by industrial consumers of the housing and communal complex;
Trends in the withdrawal of heat load consumers from CHP networks.
Reduced heat load consumption industrial enterprises and extraction of steam from the turbines of Cheboksarskaya CHPP-2 and Novocheboksarskaya CHPP-3 reduces the heating load of power units, leads to increased fuel consumption and an increase in the cost of heat and electricity.
To overcome the noted negative trends and increase the sustainability and efficiency of energy supply, the following is required:
1. Increasing the consumption of heat load and steam from the collectors of stations of all CHPPs, development of main heating networks to provide efficient heat generation heat energy for housing and communal and industrial complex cities;
2. Modernization of water treatment equipment and pumping stations, auxiliary equipment, switching equipment, relay protection systems and automation to ensure modern requirements on the safety of operation and increase the efficiency of the existing generating capacities.
3. Replacement of depleted and obsolete generating capacities with power complexes operating in the combined cycle.
Cheboksary HPP (a branch of RusHydro) Table 3.2 shows the total power of HPP generators.
Table 3.2
The operation of the Cheboksary HPP was started in 1980. The degree of wear of its hydro turbines and hydro generators is 35.5% with a total balance sheet value of equipment - 862 million rubles.
Decreased efficiency of equipment operation, limitation and underutilization of capacity for the Cheboksary HPP are due to:
Non-design (reduced) pressure at the Cheboksary HPP;
Non-design mode of operation of hydraulic turbines of the Cheboksary HPP in the "propeller" mode;
Currently, economic, environmental, technical and organizational issues of raising the level of the reservoir are being worked out.
The total installed capacity of all power plants on the territory of the republic is about 2,000 thousand kW. However, the available capacity of power plants is less than 1450 thousand kW.
Territorial Electric Grid Company OJSC Chuvashenergo includes three subdivisions of electric networks: Alatyrskoe (NPP), Northern (SES), Southern (YuES). The length of overhead lines that are on the balance sheet of OJSC Chuvashenergo is 20,933 km. At the same time, the length of overhead lines on metal supports is 282 km, including double-circuit lines - 76 km; on reinforced concrete supports - 12,560 km, including double-circuit lines - 546 km; on wooden supports - 8,091 km.
Agricultural transmission lines account for 95.6% of the total length of lines, of which 1,840 km are at a voltage of 35-110 kV; 6-10 kV - 9253 km; 0.4 kV - 9041 km.
Analysis and peer review technical condition high-voltage equipment of main networks and substations with a voltage of 220 kV and distribution networks of 6-110 kV, performed on the basis of the results of energy audits conducted by independent companies (CJSC NPO Promenergo, Samara Center for Energy Saving and Energy Efficiency, Regional Scientific and Technical and innovation center Energy Saving (RNTICE) "NP" ASINEX ", as well as express surveys, measurement and test reports of the diagnostic service of Engineering Center LLC show that there are problems associated with the hardware reliability of the power system.
An analysis of the structure of 220 kV main power grids and materials from the investigation of accidents that occurred in the power system show that there are certain shortcomings in design solutions. The most vulnerable system element in the 220 kV network is the 220 kV outdoor switchgear of the CheHPP, to which all four nodal substations and another independent source of electricity - CHPP-2 are connected radially by two 220 kV transmission lines. The 220-kV buses of CHPP-2 do not have direct autonomous connections with the nodal substations of the main networks. The Abashevo substation, which provides power supply to the consumer of the first category in terms of power supply reliability (gas pumping station), actually has only one independent source - the tires of the ORU-220kV CheHPP. It is powered by tap branches from two power lines-220kV "CheGES-Venets" and "CheGES-Kanash-2".
The main problems of 110-10-6 kV distribution networks are: steady aging of high-voltage electrical equipment; decrease in the quality of suspension and support insulators, paper-oil insulation; deterioration in the operation of the equipment of telemechanics, communications, emergency automation and relay protection systems.
According to the analysis of the diagnostic results, the most stressed elements with the largest number of developing defects in high-voltage electrical equipment include: high-voltage bushings with oil-paper insulation; load regulators (OLTC) of power transformers; contact systems of high-voltage switches; substation ground loops (due to corrosion); reinforced concrete poles of overhead lines in networks with isolated neutral (6-35 kV) and significant capacitive currents; lightning protection systems of substations, means of protecting high-voltage electrical equipment from operating switching and lightning surges. All of the above expert opinions state of high-voltage electrical equipment and the main actual problems high-voltage electrical networks also apply to substations of the generating enterprises of the CheHPP, CHPP-1, 2 and 3.
main goals further development of the main and distribution networks of the Chuvash energy system are: overcoming the aging of fixed assets of electric networks and high-voltage equipment by steadily increasing the scale of reconstruction, modernization and technical re-equipment; development of centralized technological control of electrical networks.
Electrical networks of municipal property are 26 enterprises through whose electrical networks 1,215,695 kWh are transmitted. electrical energy, or 28% of useful supply.
Technical condition of networks in countryside characterized by extreme wear. Most enterprises lack the necessary structures to properly maintain the technical condition of equipment (electrotechnical laboratories, etc.). Due to insufficient funding for the reconstruction of networks, their wear and tear annually increases by 1-2%, and in diversified public utilities, the funds received for the transportation of electrical energy are directed to finance other, unprofitable activities. The state of electric networks is critical, while there is no system of sectoral control of their state of planning for the replacement of retired capacities.
For a number of enterprises, there is no reliable information on the executive schemes of electrical networks, the composition of equipment, its actual condition, all this poses a real threat to the reliability of energy supply.
An additional threat to the reliability of energy supply is commercial losses and theft of electrical energy, which do not have a source of coverage in the tariff for the transportation of electrical energy and will form the basis of unprofitable enterprises.
The existing structure of utility power grid enterprises does not ensure the implementation of a coordinated technical policy in the power grid infrastructure of the Chuvash Republic, the attraction of investment resources for the development of electrification. This is a deterrent to the development of electrification and the implementation of socio-economic development programs in the territories, participation in the national project "affordable housing". Bringing the structure of municipal electrical networks in line with the tasks ahead is one of the top priorities.
Operational dispatch control in the electric power industry.
Chuvash branch of RDU
The sole management of the technological modes of operation of electric power facilities is carried out by the system operator of the UES of Russia (SO). Other subjects of operational dispatch control in the electric power industry (ODU in E) are subordinate to it, which are organizations or individuals authorized to issue operational dispatch commands and orders that are mandatory for ODU in E of a lower level. On the territory of the Chuvash Republic, dispatching and control of a part of the system is carried out by RDU, performing following features: operational management of energy facilities in the assigned territory, determination of systemic restrictions and proposals for their removal, forecasting and evaluation of electricity and capacity balances, calculation of dispatch schedules, organization of a balancing market and placement of reserves, long term planning, coordination of the annual schedule for repairs of equipment of power plants and power lines, organization of the functioning of operational and technological control systems of the UES: PA (emergency automation), telemechanics and communications, ASDU (automated dispatch control system), ASKUE (automated system for commercial accounting of electricity).
RDU (Nizhny Novgorod), through its representative office in Cheboksary, carries out operational and technological (dispatch) management, interacting with the control rooms of OJSC Chuvashenergo, the Chuvash branch of PJSC T + and the Cheboksary HPP.
RDU participates in the coordination of technical requirements for generating and grid companies, qualified consumers for the necessary technical monitoring and control systems for the objects of their balance sheet.
In the future, the main directions for improving regional dispatch control should be considered:
Creation of operational information complexes equipped with modern computers and specialized software products;
Construction of a regional system of automatic power control;
Implementation of digital complexes of multi-level emergency automatics;
Installation of ASKUE systems at power facilities;
Expansion of the network of linear and telephone communication, as well as telemechanics devices.
This will reduce operating costs associated with the elimination of systemic accidents, and establish operational regulation of the modes of operation of the energy system of the Czech Republic; increase the reliability of operation. automated systems operational-technological (dispatch) control (PZA, PA, ARN, ARCHM, ASDU, ASKUE and communication facilities).
Reliable functioning of the power supply system of the Czech Republic is ensured, in addition to state legal and financial regulation and control, by technical regulation. The measures of technical regulation and control (supervision) include the adoption technical regulations in the areas of technical and technological safety, the quality of electrical and thermal energy, the establishment of power reserve standards, as well as the arrangement of electrical installations of the activities of entities related to the operation of electrical and thermal equipment, including compliance with safety regulations for its maintenance.
Features of production and consumption of electricity.
Non-discriminatory access to infrastructure - ensuring equal access of market participants to electric power transmission services, operational dispatch control and wholesale market trading system administrator services.
Seasonal, daily graphs of consumption of electrical energy and power. Features of electricity generation using various technologies at stations of various types: hydroelectric power plants, pumped storage power plants, nuclear power plants, thermal power plants, state district power plants, wind farms. Combined (two product) generation at power plants, electrical and thermal energy.
The quality of electrical energy. Frequency, voltage and other quality parameters are regulated by GOST. Specifications for the connection of a consumer by an electric grid organization is issued taking into account ensuring the quality of electric energy. GOST 13109-97 “Electric energy. Compatibility of technical
means electromagnetic. Standards for the quality of electrical energy in power supply systems general purpose»
Reliability of power supply. In contracts for the provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy and energy supply, the category of reliability of supplying the consumer with electrical energy is determined, which determines the content of the obligations to ensure the reliability of the supply of electrical energy to the corresponding consumer, including:
permissible number of shutdown hours per year, not related to the consumer's failure to fulfill obligations under the relevant contracts and their termination, as well as to the circumstances force majeure and other grounds that exclude the liability of guaranteeing suppliers, energy supply, energy sales and grid organizations and other entities of the electric power industry to the consumer in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation and the terms of contracts;
power restoration period.
The first category of reliability provides for the need to ensure the continuous operation of power receiving devices, the interruption of the supply of electrical energy to which can lead to a threat to life and health of people, a threat to state security, and significant material damage.
The conditions of the second category of reliability provide for the need to ensure the reliable operation of power receiving devices, the interruption of the supply of electrical energy to which leads to unacceptable violations of technological processes of production.
Power supply to consumers not classified in the first or second reliability categories is carried out according to the third reliability category.
For the first and second categories of reliability, the permissible number of shutdown hours per year and the timing of restoration of power supply are determined by the parties depending on the specific parameters of the power supply scheme, the availability of backup power sources and features technological process consumer, but cannot be more than the corresponding values provided for the third category of reliability.
For the third category of reliability, the permissible number of shutdown hours per year is 72 hours, but not more than 24 hours in a row, including the period for restoring power supply, except for cases where longer periods are required for the repair of electric grid facilities, agreed with the federal executive body for state energy supervision.
A backup source of electrical energy supply, if the terms of the agreement on the first or second category of reliability provide for its availability, is installed by the consumer and maintained in a state of readiness for use in the event of outages or restrictions on the consumption of electrical energy. In case of failure by the consumer said requirement a backup source of electrical energy supply is installed and maintained by the grid organization at the expense of the relevant consumer, and in the event of power outages due to damage to equipment, including as a result of natural disasters, as well as due to the need to turn off the supply of electrical energy in order to eliminate the threat to life and health of people (hereinafter referred to as unscheduled outages) before the installation of such a backup source, the grid organization is not responsible for violation of the condition on the reliability category under the contract.
Wholesale Electricity (Power) Market (WECM)
The sphere of circulation of a special commodity - electrical energy (capacity) within the framework of the Unified Energy System of Russia within the boundaries of the single economic space of the Russian Federation with the participation of large producers and large buyers of electrical energy that have received the status of a wholesale market entity and act on the basis of the wholesale market rules approved in accordance with the Federal Law "On the Electric Power Industry" by the Government of the Russian Federation. The criteria for classifying producers and buyers of electrical energy as major producers and major buyers are established by the Government of the Russian Federation.
During the transition period on the wholesale market, electricity and capacity are traded using the following mechanisms:
a) trade in electrical energy (capacity) at regulated prices (tariffs) on the basis of contracts for the purchase and sale of electrical energy (capacity). Regulated contracts for several years are concluded for periods corresponding to categories of consumers of electric energy (capacity) determined in accordance with the established procedure, in respect of which the terms of the regulated contracts are differentiated.
Sale and payment for electric energy and capacity can be carried out both under a single regulated agreement providing for the purchase and sale of electric energy and capacity, and under separate regulated agreements;
b) trade in electrical energy at free (non-regulated) prices determined by agreement of the parties in bilateral contracts for the purchase and sale of electrical energy (hereinafter referred to as free bilateral contracts);
c) trade in electric energy at free (non-regulated) prices, determined by competitive selection of price bids from buyers and suppliers, carried out one day before the start of supply (hereinafter - competitive selection of price bids for the day ahead);
d) trade in electric energy in volumes corresponding to deviations at free (non-regulated) prices determined by agreement of the parties in bilateral agreements (hereinafter referred to as free bilateral agreements for the sale of deviations);
e) trade in electricity at free (non-regulated) prices, determined by competitive selection of bids from suppliers and participants with regulated consumption, carried out no later than one hour before the supply of electricity in order to form a balanced regime for the production and consumption of electricity (hereinafter - competitive selection of bids for balancing the system);
f) trade in electric energy (capacity) at regulated prices (tariffs) in order to compensate for losses, as well as to ensure the joint operation of the UES of Russia and the energy systems of foreign states.
Retail electricity markets
The subjects of retail markets are:
b) suppliers of last resort;
c) energy sales organizations;
d) energy supply organizations that sell generated or purchased electrical energy to consumers and combine this activity with the activity of transmitting electrical energy (hereinafter referred to as energy supply organizations);
e) contractors of communal services acquiring electrical energy in order to provide citizens with communal services;
f) grid organizations and other owners of electric grid facilities;
g) producers (suppliers) of electrical energy, the sale of which is not carried out on the wholesale market;
h) system operator and other subjects of operational dispatch control in technologically isolated territorial electric power systems.
The sale of electrical energy (capacity) in retail markets at regulated prices (tariffs) is carried out in volumes corresponding to those determined in accordance with the Rules of the Wholesale Electricity (Capacity) Market of the Transitional Period and Section X of the Rules of the Retail Market in the volumes of purchase of electrical energy (capacity) at regulated prices (tariffs) by guaranteeing suppliers, energy supply organizations and energy sales organizations supplying electrical energy, including for supplying citizens-consumers using electrical energy for domestic consumption.
Sale of other volumes of electric energy (capacity) in the territories of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation included in the price zones of the wholesale market is carried out at non-regulated prices in the manner established by the Rules of the retail market.
In the retail markets, electrical energy (capacity) is supplied to consumers (customers serving them) at regulated prices (tariffs) by guaranteeing suppliers, energy supply organizations and energy sales organizations, whose buyers include citizens-consumers and (or) equivalent to them in accordance with regulatory legal acts in the field of state regulation tariffs of a group (category) of consumers (buyers), in the amount purchased by the relevant organizations at regulated prices (tariffs) in the wholesale and retail markets.
The supply of electric energy to citizens-consumers and equivalent to them in accordance with regulatory legal acts in the field of state regulation of tariffs to groups (categories) of consumers (buyers) in the amount of all actual consumption is carried out at regulated prices (tariffs).
Electric energy (capacity) in excess of the volumes supplied to customers at regulated prices (tariffs) is paid for at unregulated prices within the marginal levels of unregulated prices in retail markets.
The concept of the electric power industry and its subjects
The concept of electricity. The electric power industry is the basis for the functioning of the country's economy and the life support of citizens. This is its strategic importance and role in the life of society. Electricity - ϶ᴛᴏ industry of the economy, which includes a complex of economic relations that arise in the production process (including production in the combined production and thermal energy generation mode), operational dispatch control in electric power, sales and consumption of electric energy using production and other property objects (including those included in the unified energy system). belonging to the ownership or other by federal laws, the foundation of electric power industry or other persons.
Subjects of electric power industry. In accordance with Art. 3 of the Electricity Law power industry entities are persons carrying out activities in the field of electric power industry, incl. production of electrical, thermal energy and capacity, purchase and sale of electrical energy and capacity, supply of consumers, provision of services for the transmission of electrical energy, operational dispatch control in the electric power industry, sale of electrical energy (capacity), organization of purchase and sale of electrical energy and capacity. It follows from the above definition that consumers of electric energy are not included in the circle of subjects of the electric power industry, however, they act as subjects of the wholesale and retail electricity markets.
As a result of the reform of the electric power industry, which was completed mainly by 2008, the RAO ʼʼES of Russiaʼʼ holding ceased to exist and a new structure of this industry was formed, the key elements of which are:
Organization for the management of the unified national (all-Russian) electric grid;
System operator;
Market Council;
Generation companies;
commercial operator
- distribution companies;
Sales companies;
Repair and service companies.
Along with the indicated subjects of the electric power industry, the current legislation names three more groups of subjects participating in the role of agents of the electric power sector in one or another of its areas. These groups include subjects of operational dispatch control (Article 12 of the Law on the Electricity Industry), wholesale market entities (Article 31 of the Law on the Electricity Industry), retail market entities (Article 37 of the Law on the Electricity Industry). At the same time, a part of the electric power industry entities is a member of one or another of the listed groups, and members of one group can act as members of another or other groups.
Subjects of operational dispatch control are the system operator of the Unified Energy System of Russia and other subjects of operational dispatch control (organizations and individuals) authorized to issue operational dispatch commands and orders that are mandatory for subjects of operational dispatch control of a lower level, subjects of the electric power industry and consumers of electrical energy with a controlled load within the areas of dispatch responsibility of the respective subjects of operational dispatch control, whose activities are carried out on the basis of agreements with the system operator and other subjects of operational dispatch control and under issued to operational dispatch teams and orders of subjects of operational dispatch control of a higher level.
The list of organizations exercising operational dispatch control in the electric power industry, their structure and areas of dispatch responsibility are determined by the main provisions for the functioning of the wholesale market and the rules of the wholesale market approved by the Government of the Russian Federation.
Features of the organization of operational dispatch control are established by Sec. II of the Rules for operational dispatch control in the electric power industry, approved by the Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2004 ᴦ. No. 854.
Wholesale market entities within the meaning of paragraph 1 of Art. 31 of the Law on the Electric Power Industry are participants in the circulation of electricity - suppliers of electricity (generating companies) and buyers of electricity (energy sales organizations, large consumers of electricity, guaranteeing suppliers), who have received the status of a wholesale market entity in the manner prescribed by Art. 35 of this law, as well as the administrator of the trading system of the wholesale market, organizations that ensure the functioning of the technological infrastructure of the wholesale market, incl. an organization for managing the unified national (all-Russian) electric grid and a system operator.
According to paragraph 2 of Art. 35 of the Law on Electric Power Industry, the status of objects of the wholesale market - participants in the circulation of electric energy in the wholesale market is received by:
Electricity suppliers connected to electric grids and owning or on other grounds provided for by federal laws generating equipment whose installed generating capacity exceeds the minimum allowable value established by the main provisions for the functioning of the wholesale market;
Consumers of electric energy who are connected in the established manner to electric networks and whose quantitative characteristics of the declared electricity consumption exceed the minimum allowable values established by the main provisions of the functioning of the wholesale market (large consumers of electricity);
Energy sales organizations that purchase electricity for the purpose of its subsequent sale in retail markets and whose quantitative characteristics of the declared purchase of electricity exceed the minimum allowable values established by the main provisions of the wholesale market;
Suppliers of last resort, regardless of the quantitative characteristics of the volume of electricity consumption they serve;
Territorial grid organizations in terms of paying for losses that occur in their networks.
However, within the meaning of s. 7, paragraph 2 and paragraph 5 of Art. 35 of the Law on the Electric Power Industry, the consumers of electric energy, which are the subjects of the retail markets, can also act as subjects of the wholesale market.
Retail market entities participants in relations for the production, transmission, purchase and sale and consumption of electrical energy in retail markets, as well as for the provision of services that are inextricably linked with the process of supplying electrical energy to consumers are recognized. To those in accordance with paragraph 1 of Art. 37 of the Law on Electricity include: consumers of electricity, energy sales organizations, guaranteeing suppliers, territorial grid organizations providing services for the transmission of electricity, subjects of operational dispatch management exercising the specified management at the level of retail markets; electricity producers who do not have the right to participate in the wholesale market based on article 35 of the Electricity Law.
Consumers of electrical energy within the meaning of Art. 3 of the Law on Electric Power Industry are persons who purchase electrical and thermal energy for their own domestic and (or) industrial needs.
Suppliers of last resort commercial organizations are recognized that are obliged, in accordance with the Law on the Electricity Industry or voluntarily assumed obligations, to conclude a contract for the purchase and sale of electrical energy with any consumer who has applied to him or with a person acting on behalf and in the interests of the consumer and wishing to purchase electrical energy.
Energy sales (energy supply) organizations organizations are recognized that carry out the sale of produced or purchased electric energy to other persons as their main activity.
Utility service providers legal entities are recognized regardless of the organizational and legal form, as well as individual entrepreneurs providing public utilities, producing or acquiring communal resources and responsible for the maintenance of in-house engineering networks, with the use of which utility services are provided to the consumer. The executors are a managing organization, a homeowners association, a housing construction, housing or other specialized consumer cooperative, and with direct control apartment building owners of premises - another organization producing or acquiring communal resources.
Network are organizations that own, by right of ownership or on another basis established by federal laws, electric grid facilities, with the use of which such organizations provide services for the transmission of electric energy, and also carry out, in accordance with the established procedure, the technological connection of power receiving devices (power installations) of legal entities and individuals to electric networks.
Manufacturers (suppliers)) of electric energy are recognized as owners or other legal owners of generating facilities that produce electricity (capacity) for the purpose of selling it, or other legal entities that are owners of electricity (capacity) produced at generating facilities or have the right to sell it.
The concept of the electric power industry and its subjects - the concept and types. Classification and features of the category "The concept of the electric power industry and its subjects" 2017, 2018.
